Collana |
Antichistica
Miscellanea | Wisdom Between East and West: Mesopotamia, Greece and Beyond
Capitolo | An Epistemological Perspective on the Mesopotamian Wisdom Tradition
An Epistemological Perspective on the Mesopotamian Wisdom Tradition
- Giorgio Buccellati - Cotsen Institute of Archaeology, Los Angeles, USA - email
Abstract
There are two major strands in the Mesopotamian wisdom tradition. A popular one (proverbs and folk stories) reflects what we may call a zero degree reflection on the human condition, whereas a scribal tradition hails from a more detached intellectual effort at defining this human condition especially in its moments of greater fragility. Both may be seen as a form of knowledge: reaching for a realistic assessment of what we know about ourselves. As such, it has an epistemic dimension, one that we can appreciate all the more if we compare it with myths on the one hand, which may be seen epistemologically as an idealization of nature, and epics on the other, which may be seen as an idealization of the human past. The paper develops in some detail this contrast between idealization and realism, with reference to specific texts that illuminate this shared, if differently oriented, epistemic effort.
Presentato: 07 Novembre 2023 | Accettato: 27 Marzo 2024 | Pubblicato 09 Luglio 2024 | Lingua: en
Keywords Myth • Epics • Mesopotamia • Epistemology • Wisdom
Copyright © 2024 Giorgio Buccellati. This is an open-access work distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction is permitted, provided that the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. The license allows for commercial use. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
Permalink http://doi.org/10.30687/978-88-6969-776-0/001
- Introduction
- Francesco Sironi, Maurizio Viano
- 09 Luglio 2024
Section 1. Wisdom and Knowledge
- An Epistemological Perspective on the Mesopotamian Wisdom Tradition
- Giorgio Buccellati
- 09 Luglio 2024
- Astronomy, Ṭupšarrūtu, and Knowledge in the Cuneiform World
- Francesca Rochberg
- 09 Luglio 2024
- Truth and Falsehood in Mesopotamia and Greece: Similarities and Differences
- Francesco Sironi, Maurizio Viano
- 09 Luglio 2024
Section 2. Sages and Practitioners
- Wise Man and Poet in Ancient Greece: Features and Overlaps
- Massimiliano Ornaghi
- 09 Luglio 2024
- King, Sage, Scribe, and Priest: Seleucid Uruk and Jerusalem in Perspective
- Stephanié Anthonioz
- 09 Luglio 2024
- Female Advisors Between East and West
- Jakub Kuciak, Sebastian Fink
- 09 Luglio 2024
- The Rational Roots of Medical Science Between Greece and Egypt
- Nicola Reggiani
- 09 Luglio 2024
- Dance in Hittite Culture: Choreography and Setting
- Stefano de Martino
- 09 Luglio 2024
Section 3. Literature and Wisdom Traditions
-
The Limit of Transmission
Babylonian Wisdom Literature and Wisdom in Non-cuneiform Literatures - Yoram Cohen
- 09 Luglio 2024
-
From Dialogue to Debate
Argumentative and Epic Discourse in Mesopotamian Literature Between II and I Millennium BCE - Simonetta Ponchia
- 09 Luglio 2024
- Sumerian Proverbs as Wisdom Literature
- Niek Veldhuis
- 09 Luglio 2024
- Proverbs and Wisdom Traditions in Archaic Greek Culture
- Andrea Ercolani
- 09 Luglio 2024
- Proverbs and Gnōmai in the Epic of Gilgamesh
- Bernardo Ballesteros
- 09 Luglio 2024
- Law, Morality, and Subversion in Sumerian Prose Miniatures
- Jana Matuszak
- 09 Luglio 2024
| DC Field | Value |
|---|---|
|
dc.identifier |
ECF_chapter_19205 |
|
dc.contributor.author |
Buccellati Giorgio |
|
dc.title |
An Epistemological Perspective on the Mesopotamian Wisdom Tradition |
|
dc.type |
Capitolo |
|
dc.language.iso |
en |
|
dc.description.abstract |
There are two major strands in the Mesopotamian wisdom tradition. A popular one (proverbs and folk stories) reflects what we may call a zero degree reflection on the human condition, whereas a scribal tradition hails from a more detached intellectual effort at defining this human condition especially in its moments of greater fragility. Both may be seen as a form of knowledge: reaching for a realistic assessment of what we know about ourselves. As such, it has an epistemic dimension, one that we can appreciate all the more if we compare it with myths on the one hand, which may be seen epistemologically as an idealization of nature, and epics on the other, which may be seen as an idealization of the human past. The paper develops in some detail this contrast between idealization and realism, with reference to specific texts that illuminate this shared, if differently oriented, epistemic effort. |
|
dc.relation.ispartof |
Antichistica |
|
dc.relation.ispartof |
Studi orientali |
|
dc.publisher |
Edizioni Ca’ Foscari - Venice University Press, Fondazione Università Ca’ Foscari |
|
dc.issued |
2024-07-09 |
|
dc.dateAccepted |
2024-03-27 |
|
dc.dateSubmitted |
2023-11-07 |
|
dc.identifier.uri |
http://edizionicafoscari.it/it/edizioni4/libri/978-88-6969-776-0/an-epistemological-perspective-on-the-mesopotamian/ |
|
dc.identifier.doi |
10.30687/978-88-6969-776-0/001 |
|
dc.identifier.issn |
2610-8828 |
|
dc.identifier.eissn |
2610-9344 |
|
dc.identifier.isbn |
978-88-6969-777-7 |
|
dc.identifier.eisbn |
978-88-6969-776-0 |
|
dc.rights |
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Public License |
|
dc.rights.uri |
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
|
item.fulltext |
with fulltext |
|
item.grantfulltext |
open |
|
dc.peer-review |
yes |
|
dc.subject |
Epics |
|
dc.subject |
Epistemology |
|
dc.subject |
Mesopotamia |
|
dc.subject |
Myth |
|
dc.subject |
Wisdom |
| Download data |